Last week, we found Fanny Ellsworth taking over from Joe Shaw as the Black Mask editor. She changed the magazine, selecting stories with a deeper tinge of darkness than Shaw would have. Let’s see how, taking the December 1938 issue as an example. I selected it because it’s right in the middle of Ellsworth’s reign… Continue reading Secrets of the Mask, part 11: Exploring the darkness
Category: Secrets
Secrets of the Mask, part 10: Let Darkness Fall
Last week, we took in an issue at the peak of Joe Shaw’s reign; it delivered hard-boiled at it’s peak but circulation didn’t improve. The publisher brought in a new editor, Fanny Ellsworth. She wasn’t afraid to tinker with Shaw’s formula and introduced darkness into Black Mask’s fiction. Did it work? Fanny Louise Ellsworth (1905-1983)… Continue reading Secrets of the Mask, part 10: Let Darkness Fall
Secrets of the Mask, part 9: Hard times
The seeds of greatness were there in last week’s review of an early Shaw edited issue, this week we’ll see them blossoming to their full glory in the November 1933 issue and possibly understand why hard times were happening despite that. The package The cover is by J. W. Schlaikjer, whose run of about fifty… Continue reading Secrets of the Mask, part 9: Hard times
Secrets of the Mask, part 8: February 1927, Hammett’s back
Last week, we read how Joe Shaw joined Black Mask and changed it; this week, I’m reviewing the February 1927 issue, from the first year of Joe Shaw’s editorial reign. At this point the magazine hadn’t developed into the 100% pure hard-boiled version it became later. Westerns, detective and adventure stories were promised by the… Continue reading Secrets of the Mask, part 8: February 1927, Hammett’s back
Secrets of the Mask, part 7: Shaw spells success
Last week, we found Phil Cody looking for an editor. He found the right man. Joseph T. “Cap” Shaw always wanted to be a writer and editor. He was editor of his college newspaper and a track athlete. After graduation, he became a reporter and then worked at a publishing company before joining a textile… Continue reading Secrets of the Mask, part 7: Shaw spells success
Secrets of the Mask, part 6: Unmasking Cody
A little help from my friends Last week, I was able to review an issue of Black Mask from 1925 in the middle of Phil Cody’s editorial reign. Before that happened, I could only guess at his editorial direction from looking at the covers and the tables of contents. Cody came in after George W.… Continue reading Secrets of the Mask, part 6: Unmasking Cody
Secrets of the Mask, part 5: Cody and his gunslingers
When Sutton left, Phil Cody, the circulation manager, was asked to take over the magazine. How did he do? Read on and find out. Philip Camp Cody, son of lawyer Frank and homemaker Mary Cody of Philadelphia, PA was born in 1887. He graduated from UPenn in 1908, and while I’m sure the yearbook for… Continue reading Secrets of the Mask, part 5: Cody and his gunslingers
Secrets of the Mask, part 4 – Sutton Changes
Last week, we read about the changes in the magazine’s staff when Florence M. Osborne, the first editor, left. This is an exciting moment.I’m reading an issue from George W. Sutton Jr.’s time at Black Mask. Never thought I’d find one. But when you have the right friends, amazing things can happen. And they do,… Continue reading Secrets of the Mask, part 4 – Sutton Changes
Secrets of the Mask, part 3: Sutton, who?
George W. Sutton Jr. was brought in to replace Florence M. Osborne. How did that happen? George W. Sutton Jr. (really George W. Sutton III) was the scion of a Long Island family of considerable wealth and influence. His grandfather, George W. Sutton, was a silk trader and importer who bought a twenty acre estate… Continue reading Secrets of the Mask, part 3: Sutton, who?
Secrets of the Mask, part 1- In the beginning
A recent rummage through some boxes turned up two copies of Black Mask, and I started reading them. One was from the thirties, another from the forties. I thought it might be interesting to review a few issues to see the difference in editors as the magazine changed. As I did that, I found some… Continue reading Secrets of the Mask, part 1- In the beginning